I am still seeing this stupid argument, mostly from those who hate Obamacare. “We should make Congress have the same health care plan the rest of us has! How come they’re exempt?” This is so wrong for two main reasons.
First, they’re not exempt. They have to obey the law like everyone else.
Members of Congress have the same federal health care plan as the janitors who sweep their offices. It’s the same plan the postal workers have, and the park rangers, and all federal employees. Because there are so many people who are part of this plan, it’s very cheap for the government and it provides great benefits. It saves us taxpayers money. (After all, the way to keep premiums low is to spread the risks among a huge group. And the best way to negotiate for the best benefits is to say “Well, if you give us what you want, you’ll have 10 million new members” — something only our government can do.)
But here’s the really-stupid, I-want-to-slap-people-who-say-this part: We could have all had the same health care plan as Congress gets. We could have been given the right to buy into that great federal plan. We could have shared in those benefits and paid a small premium.
Why would anyone be against that?
Well, you can guess where this is going. You got it — the Republicans forced the “public option” provision out of Obamacare. We could have all been able to buy into the federal system if we wanted to, but now we’re not allowed to. Why not? Who would it hurt? It wouldn’t cost taxpayers a cent and would probably even save them money because the risks would be spread even greater.
But no — the GOP with its insurance company backers fought against a public option and got it removed.
So the next time some Republican flunky complains that we should have gotten the same health care as the Senators, smack them for me, because the chances are, they are the very reason we don’t.
Actually, you’re wrong. Republicans did not force the public option out of ACA. At the time ACA passed Democrats had a majority in both houses. Republicans couldn’t force a thing. Center right Democrats forced the public option out of ACA and I think if you Google back to those stories you’ll find it was people like Hoyer and Max Baucus who did it.
I thought I remember that they argued that they couldn’t get the damned 60 votes unless they did that… the Democrats who removed it were, from what I recall, saying they wouldn’t get any GOP votes unless they did this. (At the time, it appeared that at least a few Republicans were going to vote for it.)
Of course, had Reid said “Screw the 60 vote thing” it wouldn’t have mattered so in that sense, yes, the Democrats were responsible.
Eventually he did say “screw the 60 vote thing.”
You are zeroing in on the reason _I_ object to the ACA: it is requiring more people to become customers of an industry which is more and more being protected from doing their jobs and even competing with each other.
I’m not at all convinced that the “public option” is the solution, but its exclusion was more pro-corporate-welfare than anti-socialism (no matter how it was sold).
“Members of Congress have the same federal health care plan as the janitors who sweep their offices. It’s the same plan the postal workers have, and the park rangers, and all federal employees.”
The only correction I would make to this is the word “plan”. It’s not a single plan. It’s a selection of plans, from which federal employees are able to choose. Some are cheap. Some are expensive. The better plans, as one might expect, are the most expensive.
I know this because I was a federal employee for eleven years. However, if you are skeptical, please refer to PolitiFact.
True enough — there are multiple plans that people can buy into, but the main point is correct: a janitor can choose to have the same plan as a Senator if he/she wants to.
Our healthcare helps pay for their healthcare? Those of us who have it. Just a theory.
Pingback: The Obamacare Lies |