“Taxation is thievery” nonsense

Nobody likes paying taxes.  Some libertarians take that to the extreme and claim that taxation is thievery.  They paint a picture of the evil government pointing guns at the helpless citizen (usually naked and wearing a barrel for some reason) implying that it is absolutely wrong for any government to demand that citizens contribute to society.

They long for a world where the government expects nothing from its citizens — you know, like no society that has ever existed in the history of the world.

Humans are social creatures, and unless you live in a shack in the woods away from everyone, you are expected to contribute to the society that provides benefits to you.  Even primitive societies demand that you take your turn gathering berries or weaving.

To demand otherwise is just selfish.

This does not mean that we can’t complain about the unfairness of our tax system.  I do that all the time.  We have a hugely unbalanced system where the average person foots the bills so the rich and the corporations don’t have to.  We could close loopholes and adjust our tax system to be fairer while reducing (if not eliminating) income tax on the majority of Americans — and we’d still be able to balance a budget.

And we can also complain about what the money is spent on.  I also do plenty of that.  We spend too much on things we don’t need, and not enough on things we do need.

There is a lot to criticize about our tax system and where the money goes.

But to turn that into “all taxation is thievery” — well, that’s just selfish nonsense.


5 thoughts on ““Taxation is thievery” nonsense

  1. When I asked a libertarian acquaintance recently about their suggested alternative to taxation, they proposed “pay as you go.” Either way, they still end up paying money for services. I suppose they justify this by thinking that they’ll get to choose what they pay for – until the local warlord annexes all of the streets in their neighborhood and has his thugs waiting at the end of their driveway with guns to collect the toll just so they can leave their own land.


  2. Pingback: What Libertarians don’t understand

  3. Pingback: That Half-Baked Thought Experiment Cooked Up by Self-Entitled Pricks. | perry street palace

  4. Don’t forget all the ‘taxation is slavery’ nonsense that goes around the same circles.

    So tired of explaining how both statements are wrong.


  5. Pingback: Flash! Libertarian acknowledges reality!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s